Zach (Brad Hunt) has been unlucky in love and long smitten with Abbey (Lauren Graham), the girl next door. When she decides to move to New York City, he's devastated and begins to plot a way to win her heart -- which leads him to consult with 12 of his ex-girlfriends. If he can find out how he failed them, maybe he'll have a shot with Abbey. Harland Williams co-stars as Zach's hapless friend Bleckman.